Hey there, beauty lovers! It’s your girl coming at you with another deep dive into the world of makeup. Today, we’re talking about a product that’s been a staple in many makeup bags for years – the MAC Pro Longwear Paint Pot. Is it worth the hype? Does it live up to its claims? Well, grab your favorite beverage, get cozy, and let’s spill the tea on this cult favorite!
First Impressions and Packaging
Let’s start with the basics. The MAC Pro Longwear Paint Pot comes in a sleek, glass pot that screams luxury. The compact size makes it perfect for tossing in your makeup bag for on-the-go touch-ups. Plus, can we talk about how satisfying it is to twist open that smooth black lid? It’s the little things, right?
The product itself has a creamy consistency that looks rich and pigmented in the pot. But as we all know, looks can be deceiving. So, let’s dive deeper into what really matters – performance!
Texture and Application
One of the most talked-about aspects of the Paint Pot is its texture. Many reviewers rave about how smooth and blendable it is. As one user, Mishameesh, puts it, “I’ve been using paint pots as an eyeshadow or eyeshadow base for years! The colors are beautiful and they never crease.”
The application process seems to be a breeze for most users. You can apply it with your fingers for a quick and easy look, or use a brush for more precise application. Maggie, a long-time user, shares, “Nothing compares to the paint pots for evening out the lid and doubling as a primer! Been using this for 20 years!!!”
However, it’s worth noting that not everyone has had a smooth experience. One user, Erica, expressed disappointment: “This product just doesn’t apply, like at all. If there is someone out there who can apply this to their eyes please, let me know cause I would love nothing more than for this to be on in my life!”
This mixed feedback suggests that while many find the Paint Pot easy to use, there might be a learning curve for some. It could be worth experimenting with different application techniques to find what works best for you.
Color Range and Pigmentation
The MAC Pro Longwear Paint Pot comes in a variety of shades, from neutral basics to more vibrant hues. Many users seem to gravitate towards the neutral shades for everyday wear, with colors like “Painterly,” “Soft Ochre,” and “Groundwork” being fan favorites.
The pigmentation seems to be a strong point for most users. As Amanda notes, “You can build it up or wear it sheer.” This versatility is a huge plus, allowing you to create anything from a subtle wash of color to a more intense look.
Some shades, like “Bare Study,” offer a bit of shimmer, which users like Rebekah love: “It’s got a nice little bit of shimmer to it. If you’re looking for a great primer with a little bit of pizazz, these are amazing!”
However, as with any product, individual experiences can vary. One user found that the “Indianwood” shade appeared more red than expected when applied, highlighting the importance of swatching or trying colors in-store when possible.
Longevity and Wear
Now, let’s talk about the “Pro Longwear” part of the name. Does it live up to its promise? According to many users, it absolutely does!
Chase Gray raves, “Works great as an eye base, even better than 24 Hour Eye Base for shadows. I find in cooler temps, the 24 Hr base flakes, whereas Painterly stays put.”
The crease-resistant formula is a major selling point for many users. Caloci, who’s been using the product for 15 years, shares, “If I lost all my makeup it is probably the first thing I would replace.”
However, it’s worth noting that a few users have experienced some creasing. Kristie424 mentions, “I remember this being crease-proof 10 years ago, but I think it’s been reformulated because it creases now.”
As always, individual experiences may vary based on factors like skin type, application technique, and the specific shade used. But overall, the longevity of the Paint Pot seems to be one of its strongest features.
Versatility
One of the most praised aspects of the MAC Pro Longwear Paint Pot is its versatility. Users love that it can serve multiple purposes in their makeup routine.
- As an Eyeshadow Base/Primer Many users swear by the Paint Pot as an eyeshadow primer. It creates a smooth canvas for powder eyeshadows, helping them to appear more vibrant and last longer. As Painterly, a 20-year user, shares, “This is a must have for me every day under my eye shadows. NEVER wrinkles, or flakes and ensures my eyeshadow outlasts my long work days.”
- As a Standalone Eyeshadow The Paint Pot isn’t just for priming; many users love wearing it on its own for a quick, put-together look. Lissa, a newer user, says, “I don’t wear a lot of eyeshadow, but this is perfect. Easy to apply and gives a sheer wash of colour just to highlight my eyes.”
- For Creating a “No-Makeup” Makeup Look The natural-looking finish of many Paint Pot shades makes them perfect for achieving that coveted “no-makeup” makeup look. Sera notes, “It’s a great every day basic – or perfect for the ‘I’m not trying’ look.”
- As a Base for Dramatic Looks While great for subtle looks, the Paint Pot also serves as an excellent base for more dramatic eye makeup. Sera adds, “It is great as a natural but enhanced daily basic, or as a blank canvas to build a more dramatic look on.”
- Unexpected Uses Some users have found creative ways to use the Paint Pot beyond its intended purpose. Jill shares an interesting use: “I actually use this on my eyebrows. I use the Taylor grey shade. I have searched high and low for an eyebrow shade that ACTUALLY has a cool/grey tone to it because all these ‘taupe’ shades that say they are a cool tone are liars.”
This versatility makes the Paint Pot a valuable addition to any makeup collection, especially for those who like to streamline their routines or get multiple uses out of a single product.
Shade Breakdown
Let’s take a closer look at some of the most popular shades:
- Painterly: This seems to be the holy grail shade for many users. It’s described as a neutral, skin-tone shade that works well for evening out lid color and as a base for other shadows.
- Soft Ochre: Another popular choice, especially for those with warmer undertones. It’s great for canceling out any discoloration on the lids.
- Groundwork: A neutral taupe shade that many users love for its versatility. It can be worn alone for a subtle look or as a base for other shadows.
- Bare Study: This shimmery shade is a favorite for those who want a bit of glow. It works well as a highlighter or as a sheer wash of color on the lids.
- Layin’ Low: Described as a natural concealer shade for medium skin tones, it’s great for creating a clean, fresh look.
- Vintage Selection: A shimmery peachy-pink shade that’s perfect for brightening up the eyes.
- Indianwood: A metallic golden bronze that can create a beautiful, warm-toned eye look.
- Blackground: An intense black shade that’s great for creating smokey eyes or as a base for dramatic looks.
Remember, the way these shades appear can vary depending on your skin tone and undertones, so it’s always a good idea to swatch before buying if possible!
Pros and Cons
After analyzing the reviews, here’s a breakdown of the main pros and cons of the MAC Pro Longwear Paint Pot:
Pros:
- Long-lasting wear
- Crease-resistant for most users
- Versatile – can be used as a primer, eyeshadow, or base
- Easy to apply for most users
- Wide range of shades available
- Buildable coverage
- Works well for creating both natural and dramatic looks
- Helps other eyeshadows appear more vibrant when used as a base
- Compact packaging good for travel
Cons:
- Some users find it difficult to apply
- Can be drying for some
- A few users experienced creasing
- Relatively expensive compared to some drugstore alternatives
- Some users noted the product dries out before they can use it all
- Limited shade range for deeper skin tones (based on available reviews)
Value for Money
At around $23 for 0.17 oz / 5 g of product, the MAC Pro Longwear Paint Pot isn’t the cheapest option on the market. However, many users feel that the quality and longevity of the product justify the price.
LongtimeMACUser shares, “Paint Pots are one of the few eyeshadow products that don’t irritate my eyes.” For those with sensitive eyes, finding a product that works well without causing irritation can be priceless.
Moreover, the versatility of the product means you’re getting multiple uses out of a single item. As Mishameesh puts it, “You need at least one of these but I promise you’ll be back for more!”
However, some users noted that the product tends to dry out before they can use it all. JSF mentions, “The only drawback is that it’s hard to get through a whole pot before it starts to dry out (lasts for years).” This could impact the value for money for some users, especially if you don’t use cream eyeshadows frequently.
Comparison to Other Products
Several users compared the Paint Pot to other popular eyeshadow primers and cream shadows:
- Urban Decay Primer Potion: Kay notes, “More dependable than my urban decay primer potion or too faced shadow insurance.”
- Bobbi Brown Cream Shadow: One user mentioned preferring the MAC Paint Pot over Bobbi Brown’s offering.
- Other MAC products: Some users compared it to MAC’s 24 Hour Eye Base, with Chase Gray stating, “Works great as an eye base, even better than 24 Hour Eye Base for shadows.
These comparisons suggest that for many users, the Paint Pot outperforms even some of the most popular alternatives on the market.
Tips and Tricks
Based on user experiences, here are some tips to get the most out of your MAC Pro Longwear Paint Pot:
- Less is More: Start with a small amount and build up if needed. The product is quite pigmented, so a little goes a long way.
- Finger Application: Many users prefer applying the product with their fingers, as the warmth helps to blend it seamlessly.
- Set with Powder: If you’re using it as a base, try setting it with a translucent powder or a matching eyeshadow to enhance its staying power.
- Prime Oily Lids: If you have very oily eyelids, consider using a separate eye primer underneath for maximum longevity.
- Experiment with Layering: Try layering different shades for unique effects, or use as a base to make your powder eyeshadows pop.
- Use as a Color Corrector: Some users found success using certain shades to color correct discoloration on their eyelids.
- Keep it Sealed: To prevent the product from drying out, always ensure the lid is tightly closed after use.
- Revive Dried Product: If your Paint Pot starts to dry out, try adding a drop of facial oil or Duraline to revive it.
Personal Experience and Final Thoughts
As a beauty blogger who’s tried countless eye products, I have to say the MAC Pro Longwear Paint Pot has earned its place as a staple in my makeup routine. The versatility alone makes it a winner in my book – on busy mornings, I can swipe on a bit of Painterly for an instantly polished look, and on days when I want to go all out, it creates the perfect base for more elaborate eye looks.
What I love most about this product is its staying power. Living in a city with unpredictable weather, I need my makeup to withstand everything from sudden downpours to sweaty subway rides. The Paint Pot delivers on this front, keeping my eye makeup intact from my morning coffee run to after-work drinks.
That said, I do understand some of the criticisms. The learning curve can be steep if you’re not used to cream products, and finding the right shade for your skin tone might take some trial and error. And yes, the price point is higher than some alternatives, but in my experience, the quality justifies the cost.
One thing I’d love to see from MAC is an expansion of the shade range, especially for deeper skin tones. While the current lineup is beautiful, there’s always room for more inclusivity in the beauty world.
In conclusion, while no product is perfect for everyone, the MAC Pro Longwear Paint Pot comes pretty close in my book. Its long-wearing formula, versatility, and range of beautiful shades make it a worthy addition to any makeup collection. Whether you’re a makeup newbie looking for an easy, one-and-done product, or a seasoned beauty enthusiast seeking the perfect eyeshadow base, the Paint Pot is definitely worth considering.
Remember, makeup is all about experimentation and finding what works for you. So why not give the MAC Pro Longwear Paint Pot a try? You might just discover your new holy grail product!
Until next time, stay beautiful inside and out!
Buy On Amazon: Here