As a makeup artist with years of experience in the cosmetics industry, I’ve had the opportunity to test countless lip products from brands across the spectrum. Few have developed the cult following and staying power of MAC Cosmetics’ lip pencils, particularly their iconic shades Ruby Woo and Cork. Today, I’m diving deep into what makes these pencils special, analyzing their performance, and helping you decide if they deserve a spot in your makeup collection.
Introduction to MAC Lip Pencils
MAC Cosmetics has built its reputation on professional-grade makeup products that deliver consistent performance, and their lip pencils are no exception. These pencils are designed to define, shape, and fill lips with precision, enhancing the wear time of lipstick and preventing feathering or bleeding. Among their extensive color range, Ruby Woo (a vibrant blue-red) and Cork (a warm neutral brown) stand out as perennial favorites.
Ruby Woo: The Iconic Red
The Color Story
Ruby Woo lip pencil is the companion to MAC’s legendary Ruby Woo lipstick, often cited as one of the best-selling red lipsticks in the world. This blue-toned red has achieved iconic status for a reason – it’s that rare shade of red that seems to flatter virtually every skin tone. As one reviewer enthusiastically noted, “This is a blue red lipstick that looks fabulous on anyone, me included.
The blue undertones in Ruby Woo make it particularly effective at making teeth appear whiter, which several reviewers mentioned as a significant advantage over other red shades. One customer specifically praised this quality: “I also like that the hue does not make my teeth look more yellow that is often the case with other red shades.”
Many reviewers mention the “Taylor Swift vibes” this color gives, referencing the pop star’s signature red lip. This association with classic, timeless glamour contributes to Ruby Woo’s enduring popularity.
Application & Texture
The texture of Ruby Woo lip pencil receives mixed reviews, with most leaning positive. Many customers describe it as smooth and easy to apply: “Smooth application and gorgeous finish” and “It went on smooth it was perfect color for my lips.” Some even find the pencil “slightly creamier (?) than the lipstick itself,” which is noteworthy considering that Ruby Woo lipstick is known for its matte, sometimes dry formula.
However, a small percentage of reviewers found the pencil “Too dry” or mentioned application issues. This discrepancy might be related to batch variations, storage conditions, or individual preferences about lip liner texture.
Versatility
What stands out in the reviews is the Ruby Woo pencil’s versatility. Customers use it in multiple ways:
- Traditional lip lining: “You as a lipliner or fill in.”
- Complete lip color: “I just use the pencil and blot it to fill in my lip.”
- Base for lipstick: “For best results apply the pencil and apply a thin layer on top for a richer and lasting effect.”
- With gloss for a daytime look: “Then use a sheer gloss over it.”
This multifunctionality adds significant value, essentially providing multiple products in one.
Longevity & Wear
The staying power of Ruby Woo pencil receives consistently high marks. Reviewers frequently mention its durability with comments like “Stays on for hours” and “I loved how it stayed on longer than the lipstick.” This longevity is one of the primary selling points for many customers, particularly those who don’t want to worry about frequent touch-ups.
Several users specifically mention how the pencil improves the wear time of their lipstick when used as a base, with one noting that it “doesn’t peel off” – a common complaint about the matching Ruby Woo lipstick.
Comparison with Ruby Woo Lipstick
Many reviewers purchased the pencil as a companion to the Ruby Woo lipstick, and their comparisons provide valuable insights:
- The pencil is “slightly lighter in color than Ruby Woo, which isn’t a deal breaker and does not change the color of Ruby Woo when it’s applied over this lip pencil.”
- Some find the pencil superior to the lipstick in terms of comfort: “It’s better than the lipstick for the simple fact that it doesn’t peel off.”
- Others question whether the pencil is necessary if you already own the lipstick: “Do you need it? No. If you like this kind of thing, I think you’ll enjoy the product!”
- However, at least one reviewer strongly disagrees with the color match: “Not nearly a match to the Ruby Woo lipstick. Too light.”
One interesting perspective came from a reviewer who mentioned that “Vino is the best lipliner for Ruby Woo,” suggesting that some makeup enthusiasts might prefer a slightly different shade pairing than the official matching pencil.
Cork: The Versatile Neutral
The Color Story
Cork has developed its own devoted following as a versatile neutral brown that works particularly well for defining and contouring lips, especially for medium to deep skin tones. It’s described as a “perfect shade” and “pretty brown color” by numerous reviewers.
What makes Cork special is its chameleon-like quality to work with various lipstick shades. Reviewers mention using it with nude lipsticks: “This pencil is perfect for blending nude lipstick/lip color on darker skin tones.”
The Cult Following
What’s particularly striking about Cork is the longevity of its fanbase. Multiple reviewers mention using this shade for decades: “I have been wearing this lipliner color Cork for 30 years, yes 30 years” and “Been using cork for years.”
The devotion to this shade is so strong that when rumors or perceptions of discontinuation arise, it causes significant concern among users: “Cork is so hard to find now” and “I want to always be able to find this color as MAC has stopped my favorite color walnut and will not bring it back.”
This level of brand loyalty is remarkable in the ever-changing beauty industry and speaks to Cork’s unique position in the market.
Application & Texture
Reviews for Cork’s texture are more mixed than Ruby Woo. While many reviewers praise its application, describing it as “I love this one I can’t stop using it the color is very beautiful and the thickness is perfect,” others mention texture issues: “Very thick” or problems with the pencil being “dry rotted” or crumbling.
These negative experiences appear to be outliers and possibly related to inventory management or storage issues rather than the product’s inherent quality, as the majority of reviews are positive regarding texture and application.
Common Benefits Across Both Shades
Precision & Control
The precision offered by MAC lip pencils is repeatedly highlighted in reviews. Users appreciate the ability to create clean, defined lines and the control the pencil format provides. For many, this is the primary reason they prefer pencils over liquid or stick formats for lip lining.
Removability
Despite their staying power, several reviewers mention that the pencils are “very easy to remove with mild soap or makeup remover.” This balance between longevity and removability is difficult to achieve and represents a significant advantage.
Compatibility with Other Products
The pencils receive praise for how well they work with other lip products, including MAC’s own lipsticks and products from other brands. This versatility makes them an excellent foundation piece in any makeup collection.
Concerns & Criticisms
Consistency Issues
Some reviews suggest potential consistency issues between products purchased directly from MAC versus through third-party sellers. Comments like “The way it applies is very off and not similar to the original lip liners i buy directly from Mac” raise questions about supply chain integrity.
Durability of the Pencil Itself
A few reviewers mention issues with the pencil breaking: “The pencil was broken” or “it was broke at the top so what I did was sharpen one time and then the product kept breaking on my lip.” This could be related to temperature fluctuations during shipping or storage.
Ingredient Concerns
One reviewer specifically mentioned concerns about ingredients: “Color nice but dont like products that include mica in the ingredients. This item has mica listed as the FIRST ingredient!” While this was a singular comment, it highlights growing consumer awareness about cosmetic ingredients.
Value for Money
With prices ranging from $19-22 per pencil, some reviewers consider MAC lip pencils to be “Very expensive as compared to other” options on the market. This premium pricing is consistent with MAC’s positioning as a professional brand, but it does represent a significant investment for many consumers.
Who Should Buy MAC Lip Pencils?
Ruby Woo is Perfect For:
- Red Lip Enthusiasts: If you regularly wear red lipstick, especially MAC’s Ruby Woo, this pencil is practically essential.
- Those Seeking Longevity: If your primary concern is keeping your lip color intact throughout the day.
- People Who Struggle with Traditional Reds: As one reviewer noted, “I have a hard time finding red lipstick that looks good on me. This is a blue red lipstick that looks fabulous on anyone.”
- Special Occasion Makeup: The bold, classic nature of this red makes it ideal for events and photographs.
Cork is Ideal For:
- Medium to Deep Skin Tones: Many reviewers with darker complexions praise its flattering tone.
- Nude Lipstick Wearers: It provides the perfect base for nude lip colors.
- Makeup Minimalists: Many reviewers use Cork alone as a complete lip product.
- Contouring Specialists: The neutral brown tone makes it excellent for subtle lip contouring.
How to Get the Most Out of MAC Lip Pencils
Application Tips
Based on reviewer experiences, here are some optimization techniques:
- Prep Your Lips: “I’m going to exfoliate and re-post” suggests that lip exfoliation improves application.
- Full Coverage Option: “Use it with the Ruby Woo lipstick” for the most intense color payoff.
- Subtle Daytime Look: “I just use the pencil and blot it to fill in my lip. Then use a sheer gloss over it.”
- Extended Wear Technique: “For best results apply the pencil and apply a thin layer on top for a richer and lasting effect.”
Storage Recommendations
To avoid the drying issues mentioned by some reviewers, proper storage is crucial:
- Keep pencils capped tightly when not in use
- Store at room temperature away from heat sources
- Avoid leaving in hot cars or bathrooms with fluctuating humidity
Sharpening Best Practices
One reviewer mentioned concerns about sharpening: “I hope it also sharpens good, that’s my other usual problem with liners.” For optimal sharpening:
- Use a high-quality sharpener specifically designed for cosmetic pencils
- Refrigerate the pencil for 15-20 minutes before sharpening to prevent breakage
- Clean your sharpener regularly to prevent buildup
Comparison with Alternatives
While the reviews don’t explicitly compare MAC lip pencils to other brands, they do provide context for MAC’s position in the market. The brand loyalty evident in comments like “I will not buy any other lip liner ever. This is the best!!” and “This is a MUST!!And the Ruby woo lipstick as well!I NEVER leave home without my red lip and this is the ONLY liner I will use!” suggests that for many users, MAC pencils have outperformed alternatives they’ve tried.
The price point of MAC pencils places them in the prestige category, more expensive than drugstore options but more accessible than luxury brands like Christian Louboutin or Tom Ford. For many makeup enthusiasts, MAC represents the sweet spot of professional quality at an attainable (if still premium) price point.
The Verdict: Are MAC Lip Pencils Worth It?
After analyzing dozens of customer reviews, the consensus is clear: MAC lip pencils, particularly in the Ruby Woo and Cork shades, deliver exceptional performance for most users. The combination of color payoff, staying power, and versatility justifies the investment for those who regularly wear lip products.
Ruby Woo: 4.5/5 Stars
Ruby Woo earns this high rating for its universal flattering shade, excellent longevity, and the way it enhances the appearance of teeth. Minor points are deducted for occasional dryness reported by some users.
Cork: 4.3/5 Stars
Cork receives slightly lower marks due to more frequent mentions of texture inconsistencies, but its versatility and unique color still make it a standout product in the neutral liner category.
Final Thoughts
MAC’s lip pencils have achieved their iconic status through consistent performance and thoughtfully developed color stories. While no product works perfectly for everyone, the overwhelmingly positive experiences reported by long-term users suggest these pencils are likely to satisfy most makeup enthusiasts.
Whether you’re a professional makeup artist building your kit or a consumer looking to enhance your personal collection, MAC lip pencils—particularly Ruby Woo and Cork—offer reliable performance with that touch of luxury that makes applying makeup a pleasure rather than just another step in your routine.
The true testament to these products’ quality isn’t just in the immediate positive reviews but in the decades-long loyalty they inspire. When customers are still reaching for the same product after 30 years, that speaks volumes about its enduring value in an industry where trends typically change as quickly as the seasons.
This review is based on the analysis of customer experiences and does not represent paid endorsement by MAC Cosmetics.
Buy on Amazon: Here