Hey there, lipstick lovers! Today we’re diving deep into one of MAC’s most popular lip products – their Amplified Lipstick. As a self-professed lipstick junkie, I couldn’t wait to dig through the hundreds of customer reviews to get the real scoop on this creamy, pigmented formula. Is it truly a must-have for every makeup bag or an over-hyped product that doesn’t live up to the name? Let’s find out!
First Impressions: What Customers are Raving About
Right off the bat, it’s clear that MAC Amplified Lipstick has earned quite the fan club. Loyal customers can’t stop gushing about the creamy texture, bold color payoff, and comfortable wear. Here are some of the most common praises I spotted:
“Smooth application and stays on really well” – Rennie, 55-64 “If you are looking for something quiet and sexy, you have to try Modesty!!” – Mommahotchicken, 45-54 “I feel like a million buck when I wear this lip stick!” – Rubyred, 45-54 “So smooth & longlasting.” – MVee
Those are some serious compliments! It seems like MAC nailed it with a formula that glides on effortlessly, delivers intense pigmentation, and has some serious staying power. As someone who’s always on the hunt for a lipstick that can survive my morning coffee and afternoon snacks, I’m definitely intrigued.
The Good, The Bad, The Meh: Digging Deeper into Reviews
Of course, no product is perfect, and even the most beloved lipsticks have their flaws. While the vast majority of reviews for MAC Amplified Lipstick are glowingly positive, there were a few recurring criticisms that are worth noting.
The most common complaint? The shade range. Several reviewers expressed disappointment in the color selection, wishing for more options that truly flatter a wide range of skin tones. As reviewer maddamn put it:
I wish Mac had more of a focus on curating a more flattering collection of lipstick colours. I think it would be worthwhile to have a professional colour analyst on their team that helps develop colours and categorize them by season (i.e. true summer, dark winter, etc.). The colours on their own are pretty but that doesn’t mean anything if they’re not flattering on peoples complexions.”
This is a fair point – while MAC certainly offers an impressive number of shades, they may not all be universally flattering. It seems like the brand could benefit from a more intentional approach to color curation, taking into account different skin tones and undertones.
Another issue that popped up a few times? Consistency. While most reviewers raved about the creamy, moisturizing texture, a handful noted that their lipstick turned rancid or had a strange smell after a few months. Reviewer Shadow Witch had this to say:
“It gets 3 stars for the shade but I had to deduct 2 stars because this lipstick turned on me. Twice. The last two I purchased turned rancid after only 6 months. I have never had this happen with any of the hundreds of MAC lipsticks I have purchased over the last 40 years. Weird.”
Yikes! There’s nothing worse than reaching for your favorite lippie only to find it’s gone bad. While this doesn’t seem to be a widespread problem, it’s definitely something to keep in mind. Make sure you’re storing your MAC Amplified Lipstick properly (in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight) and keep an eye on the expiration date.
Top-Rated Shades: The Colors Customers Can’t Get Enough Of
Now, let’s talk about the fun stuff – the shades that customers are absolutely obsessed with. While preferences definitely vary, there were a few standout hues that earned rave review after rave review.
Blankety
This pale beige-pink is a fan-favorite for its versatility and “my lips but better” effect. Reviewer EH gushes, “Blankety is my favorite shade of any lipstick ever. It’s the only lipstick I’ve ever run out of and bought again. On my 3rd tube.” Talk about a holy grail product!
Cosmo
If you’re looking for the perfect red, Cosmo might just be your match. Reviewer Ms. M describes it as a “nice red for those of us with a yellow undertone,” noting that it “works well alone or with a darker pencil to make a more burgundy tone.” Versatile and flattering? Sign me up.
Crème Cup
This pretty pink has won the hearts of countless MAC fans for its creamy formula and gorgeous color. Reviewer KMS boldly states, “I’ve tried MANY lipsticks over the years, and this is, by far, the BEST EVER!!! Beautiful color (Crème Cup) and beautiful finish! I ordered one to try, and have already ordered three more! Please don’t ever change or discontinue this lipstick and this color! If I could give it 10 stars, I would!” With an endorsement like that, I’m sold.
Of course, these are just a few of the many beloved shades in the MAC Amplified Lipstick range. Other top-rated hues include Mocha, a deep brown-rose; Myth, a pale beige-pink; and Brave, a pinky-beige nude. No matter your skin tone or preferred look, there’s sure to be a shade that speaks to you.
The Best Skin Tones and Looks for MAC Amplified Lipstick
One thing that’s clear from the reviews? MAC Amplified Lipstick works well on a wide range of skin tones, from fair to deep. However, there are definitely certain shades and finishes that seem to be more flattering for specific complexions.
For fair skin, reviewers recommend sticking with light, cool-toned pinks and nudes like Crème Cup and Blankety. As Pinkie notes, “For context I am fair skinned with cool undertones and this color [Crème Cup] is almost my exact lip color. So flattering and an easy, everyday neutral.”
Medium and olive skin tones seem to have more flexibility, with reviewers raving about everything from bold reds to deep browns to rosy mauves. Reviewer OpalEagle, who describes their complexion as “fair skin”, loves the shade Smoked Almond, calling it “an absolute win if you want that perfect petal shade. It’s almost a mix between terra cotta and coral with enough red-brown to give a rosy effect.”
For deep skin tones, MAC Amplified Lipstick offers some seriously gorgeous options. Reviewer MJ, who is NW50, says of the shade Myth: “Very well pigmented, you need a light hand for application or it can be too much for a simple look. I’m NW50 and this serves as a pink-dominant nude and needs a liner like Chestnut to really make it pop.”
No matter your skin tone, the key seems to be finding a shade that enhances your natural coloring without overwhelming it. And don’t be afraid to experiment with different finishes and undertones – you never know what might become your new signature look!
Pro Tips: How to Make the Most of Your MAC Amplified Lipstick
As I read through the reviews, I couldn’t help but jot down some of the brilliant tips and tricks customers shared for getting the most out of their MAC Amplified Lipstick. Here are a few of my favorites:
- “Myth is my absolute favorite stick to have on hand. It can change any dark lipstick to a perfect toned down shade. It mixes well with spice lipliner to get the most perfect nude lip. Team It up with oh baby lipgloss and you have a plump neutral lip.” – Breebee, 45-54
- “I usually stir clear of super bold colors but this lipstick really brings out my golden/olive undertones and the hazel/brown in my eyes. I’m sad to see it on Last Chance! Considering ordering another tube just to have it on hand.” – Mandy, 25-34
- “If you add on some lip glass on top it’s chef kiss” – bambinaa, 25-34
I love the idea of using a light shade like Myth to tone down bolder colors or create a custom nude. And pairing your MAC Amplified Lipstick with a complementary liner and gloss? Genius! These are the kinds of pro tips you can only get from real customers who have put the product to the test.
The Final Verdict: Is MAC Amplified Lipstick Worth the Hype?
After poring over hundreds of reviews and swatching my way through the shade range, I’ve come to a conclusion: MAC Amplified Lipstick is a creamy, pigmented powerhouse that lives up to its cult-favorite status.
While no product is perfect (the shade range could use some work and there have been a few complaints about consistency), the overwhelming majority of customers are head-over-heels for this iconic lipstick. From the smooth, comfortable texture to the bold color payoff to the impressive staying power, MAC Amplified Lipstick checks all the boxes for a truly fantastic lip product.
Is it worth the hype? In my opinion, absolutely. Whether you’re a die-hard MAC fan or a lipstick newbie, this is a formula that deserves a spot in your collection. With so many gorgeous shades to choose from and endless ways to customize your look, you really can’t go wrong.
So go ahead, treat yourself to a tube (or three) of MAC Amplified Lipstick. Your lips will thank you!
Top Takeaways
- MAC Amplified Lipstick is a creamy, pigmented formula with serious staying power
- While the shade range is extensive, some reviewers wish for more universally flattering colors
- Consistency can be hit or miss, with a few reports of lipsticks turning rancid prematurely
- Top-rated shades include Blankety (pale beige-pink), Cosmo (yellow-toned red), and Crème Cup (pretty pink)
- Works well on a wide range of skin tones, but certain shades and finishes may be more flattering for specific complexions
- Pro tips: Use a light shade to tone down bold colors, pair with liner and gloss for a custom look
And there you have it, my loves – the ultimate guide to MAC Amplified Lipstick. I hope this in-depth review has helped you decide if this cult-favorite formula is right for you. As always, I’d love to hear your thoughts! Have you tried MAC Amplified Lipstick? What’s your go-to shade? Leave a comment below and let’s chat all things lipstick.
Until next time, pucker up and stay fabulous! Xx
Buy on Amazon: Here