Hey there, beauty lovers! Today, we’re diving deep into MAC’s latest lip product – the M·A·Cximal Silky Matte Lipstick. This new release has been generating quite the buzz, with popular shades like Velvet Teddy, Taupe, Mehr, and Honeylove getting a fresh makeover. As a long-time MAC fan and lipstick aficionado, I couldn’t wait to get my hands on these beauties and share my thoughts with you all.
But before we get into my personal experience, I wanted to analyze the wealth of customer reviews out there to get a comprehensive view of how this lipstick is being received. I’ve pored over dozens of reviews, from MAC loyalists to new converts, to bring you the key takeaways. Let’s see what the MAC community has to say!
The Formula: Matte But Moisturizing
One of the most prominent themes across the reviews was praise for the unique formula MAC has achieved with the M·A·Cximal Silky Matte Lipstick. Many reviewers, myself included, have often found traditional matte lipsticks to be drying and uncomfortable to wear for extended periods. However, it seems MAC has cracked the code with this new release.
Reviewer after reviewer raved about how this lipstick manages to deliver a true matte finish without sacrificing comfort. Take this glowing review from Chasemice:
“It’s not so drying, which I love.”
And this one from Very classy!:
“The lipstick is honestly quite long lasting, but it won’t stay after eating food.. lol it only requires a light touch up post lunch though.”
Many attributed this to the lipstick’s moisturizing properties, with reviewers like Bianca noting:
“It’s beautiful and easy to wear but will it replace the Retro Matte Ruby Woo for me? No. However, it’s nice to have when I don’t feel like wearing too dry of a lipstick.”
As someone who’s perpetually seeking that perfect balance between a polished matte look and all-day comfort, I’m thrilled to see a formula that seemingly delivers on both fronts. Kudos to MAC for this innovation!
Pigmentation & Staying Power
Another aspect that stood out in the reviews was the impressive pigmentation and long-wearing nature of the M·A·Cximal Silky Matte Lipstick. Bold, vibrant color payoff was consistently mentioned as a pro, with reviewers like Arshie gushing:
“This shade is so pretty and it compliments my skin tone so well. Theformula is comfortable to wear.”
Many reported that a single swipe delivered rich, opaque color that lasted for hours without touch-ups. Spam shared:
“So comfortable to wear and a beautiful bold neutral that everyone can wear”
And Surfing68 said:
“The new formula is excellent, no doubt about that.”
As a busy gal always on the go, I deeply appreciate a lipstick that can keep up with my lifestyle. From the looks of it, the M·A·Cximal Silky Matte Lipstick fits the bill perfectly.
The Shades: New Takes On Old Favorites
MAC’s shade range has always been one of its biggest strengths, and it seems they’ve hit the mark again with this release. The M·A·Cximal Silky Matte Lipstick comes in a mix of brand new hues and fresh interpretations of cult-classic shades.
Velvet Teddy, a long-time bestseller, received several shout-outs. Mo raved:
“I wear this almost everyday, nice shade for work and school. It’s long lasting and my lips feel really comfortable.”
While Katie shared:
“Velvet Teddy is probably my favourite. It’s warm and complements my skin tone, lasts most of the day, and has great pigmentation.”
Ruby Woo, another iconic MAC shade, seemed to be more divisive in its new iteration. Ms. Ruby woo expressed disappointment:
“I am returning my tube of lipstick as this new oil takes away the blue undertones. I have been wearing this same shade since the age of 24 and I loved it.”
However, Alex had the opposite experience:
“I can’t get enough of the new formula! I’ve loved the Ruby Woo colour for years but found the old formula too drying for my dry skin. This is a game changer.”
Personally, I love seeing brands breathe new life into fan-favorite shades. While reformulations can be hit or miss, I appreciate MAC’s effort to make some of their most beloved colors more wearable for a wider range of people.
The Misses: Not For Everyone
Of course, no product is perfect, and the M·A·Cximal Silky Matte Lipstick had its fair share of detractors. The most common complaint seemed to be around shades not living up to expectations. Sarah B lamented:
“I’m really disappointed with the new colour I immediately noticed the difference. I loved the old colour it was my favourite go to colour.”
And Ang shared a similar sentiment:
“This is the third reformulation ( from other makeup) I have had to move on from since Covid . Leave the products alone . I do not like the new product at all.”
Some reviewers, like Mocha, took issue with the formula itself:
I hate this formular too drying as powder kiss formular why mac have shift the stain colours to this silly formular . I don’t understand .”
As with all makeup, what works for some won’t work for others. Lipstick in particular can be so personal – the way a shade pulls on different skin tones, how a formula feels on one person’s lips versus another’s. I always encourage my readers to take reviews (even mine!) with a grain of salt and, when possible, try products out for themselves.
The Verdict
So, where does this leave us with the M·A·Cximal Silky Matte Lipstick? After analyzing dozens of reviews and trying the product myself, I’ve concluded it’s a worthy addition to any lipstick lover’s collection – with a few caveats.
If you’re a fan of classic MAC shades like Velvet Teddy, Taupe, Mehr, or Honeylove and have been craving an updated formula, I think you’ll be thrilled with this release. The colors are true to the originals with the added benefit of a more comfortable, moisturizing wear.
For those loyal to the Retro Matte or Powder Kiss formulas, I’d suggest proceeding with caution. The M·A·Cximal Silky Matte Lipstick has a distinctly different feel on the lips that may not be your cup of tea if you’re ride-or-die for those finishes.
And of course, as with any lipstick purchase, I always recommend swatching in person if you can. Shades can look vastly different based on your unique skin tone and undertones. But if online shopping is more your speed, look for reviewers with similar coloring to yours to get the best sense of how a color might look on you.
All in all, I think MAC has delivered a solid new formula with the M·A·Cximal Silky Matte Lipstick. It’s not going to be everyone’s holy grail, but it fills a much-needed niche for those seeking a truly comfortable matte lip. I personally can’t wait to rock Velvet Teddy and Mehr on the regular.
What about you, loves? Have you tried the M·A·Cximal Silky Matte Lipstick yet? If so, I’m dying to hear your thoughts. Drop a comment below and let’s chat all things lipstick!
Until next time, stay beautiful – inside and out.
