In the ever-evolving world of beauty products, finding the perfect mascara can feel like searching for a needle in a haystack. Today, I’m taking an in-depth look at MAC’s Waterproof Mascara, a product that has generated considerable buzz in the beauty community. With a price point of approximately $27, this high-end mascara promises waterproof performance while delivering length and volume to your lashes. But does it live up to these claims? After analyzing numerous customer experiences and examining its performance across various conditions, I’ll break down everything you need to know before investing in this premium mascara.
First Impressions and Packaging
MAC’s signature sleek black packaging exudes the professional-grade quality the brand is known for. The mascara comes in a cylindrical tube that feels substantial in the hand—a small but significant detail that contributes to the premium experience. The wand features a rounded tip, which multiple users praised for its precision, particularly when applying product to those hard-to-reach corner lashes.
However, some customers reported issues with the packaging itself. Several mentioned receiving products where the wand was loose, bent, or wobbly, making application nearly impossible. While these appear to be isolated quality control issues rather than design flaws, it’s worth noting since the product is often non-returnable through certain retailers.
Application Experience
Formula Consistency
The formula of MAC’s Waterproof Mascara presents a bit of a paradox. When first opened, many users report that the mascara applies smoothly and evenly, creating beautifully defined lashes with minimal effort. The consistency initially appears to strike that perfect balance—not too wet and not too dry.
However, one of the most consistent criticisms centers around how quickly the formula seems to change after opening. Multiple reviews indicate that the mascara begins to clump and thicken after just a week or two of use. This rapid change in consistency is particularly disappointing given the premium price point.
Brush Design
The applicator features a traditional brush design with a rounded tip. This design receives mixed reviews:
Pros:
- The rounded tip allows for precise application to corner lashes
- When the formula is fresh, the brush distributes product evenly
Cons:
- As the formula thickens, the brush seems to hold excess product, leading to clumping
- Some users found the brush stiffer than expected, which affected application
Buildability
When the product is fresh, many users praise its buildability. The formula allows for layering without immediate clumping, enabling both natural and more dramatic looks depending on application technique. However, this quality appears to diminish as the product ages, with second and third coats becoming increasingly problematic after the first week or so of use.
Performance
Lengthening and Volumizing Effects
The mascara generally receives high marks for its lengthening capabilities. Even critics who disliked other aspects of the product acknowledged that it effectively elongates lashes. The volumizing effect is more divisive—some users experienced dramatic fullness, while others found the results more subtle.
For those with naturally thin or short lashes, the lengthening effect seems particularly impressive. Several reviews mentioned that the mascara made their lashes appear significantly longer, eliminating the need for false lashes in some cases.
Waterproof Claims
This is where the MAC Waterproof Mascara truly shines for most users. The majority of reviews confirm that the waterproof claims hold up impressively well:
- Multiple users tested it in extreme conditions (swimming, heavy sweating, 115-degree heat) and reported no smudging or running
- Several reviewers specifically mentioned that this was the first truly waterproof mascara they had found after trying numerous other brands
- Even those who experienced flaking did not generally report smudging or raccoon eyes
However, a small minority of users questioned the waterproof claims, noting that the product failed when their eyes watered. This discrepancy might be due to differences in application technique or individual skin chemistry.
Longevity and Wear
When it comes to all-day wear, the mascara performs admirably for most users. Key observations include:
- Minimal to no smudging throughout the day, even for users who reported touching their eyes frequently
- Consistent appearance from morning to evening with little degradation
- No need for touch-ups during the day
That said, the flaking issue appeared in numerous reviews. While the mascara doesn’t tend to smudge or run, flaking seems to be a common experience, particularly as the product ages or when multiple coats are applied.
Removal Process
The flip side of excellent waterproof performance is often difficult removal, and MAC’s Waterproof Mascara is no exception. Reviews are split on this aspect:
- Some users appreciate the tenacity, seeing it as proof of the product’s waterproof claims
- Others found removal excessively difficult, requiring oil-based makeup removers and significant rubbing
- Several users specifically mentioned using mineral oil as the most effective removal method
This difficulty in removal makes it less suitable for daily wear for some users, who prefer to reserve it for special occasions or situations where waterproof performance is essential.
Longevity in the Tube
One of the most significant criticisms of the MAC Waterproof Mascara concerns how quickly it dries out or changes consistency after opening. Multiple reviews mentioned:
- Noticeable thickening and clumping after just one week of use
- Complete drying out within a month for some users
- Significant changes in application experience from first use to subsequent applications
This rapid deterioration is particularly disappointing given the premium price point. Many users expressed frustration that such an expensive product would have such a short effective lifespan.
Value Proposition
At approximately $27 per tube, MAC’s Waterproof Mascara sits firmly in the high-end mascara category. Whether it represents good value depends heavily on individual priorities:
Value Drivers:
- Truly waterproof formula that withstands extreme conditions
- Excellent lengthening capabilities
- No smudging or raccoon eyes throughout the day
Value Detractors:
- Rapid formula degradation after opening
- Clumping issues that arise quickly
- Flaking reported by many users
- Packaging/quality control issues reported by some
Several reviews explicitly mentioned feeling disappointed by the value, comparing the performance to drugstore mascaras costing less than half the price. Others, however, considered it well worth the investment for its waterproof capabilities alone.
Comparison to Competitors
A few reviews offered direct comparisons to other mascaras, providing valuable context:
- Several users mentioned trying “a million other mascaras” and finding MAC’s Waterproof to be superior
- One detailed comparison with L’Oreal’s “Bambi Eye” waterproof mascara noted that the drugstore option performed better in terms of clumping and buildability
- Lancôme waterproof mascaras were mentioned as excellent alternatives but with similar drying issues
For those specifically seeking a truly waterproof formula, MAC’s offering appears to outperform many competitors, but at a higher price point and with some formula consistency issues.
Best For
Based on the collective feedback, MAC’s Waterproof Mascara seems best suited for:
- Those who prioritize genuinely waterproof performance above all else
- Users who struggle with mascara smudging or raccoon eyes
- People who need mascara to withstand extreme conditions (swimming, high humidity, workouts)
- Those looking for significant lengthening effects
It may be less ideal for:
- Daily, everyday wear due to removal difficulties and rapid formula deterioration
- Those sensitive to flaking
- Users seeking primarily volumizing effects
- Budget-conscious shoppers who expect long-lasting tube life
Application Tips from Users
Savvy users shared several techniques to maximize performance:
- Use a lash comb immediately after application to separate lashes and minimize clumping
- Apply quickly before the formula begins to dry on the lashes
- Limit to one coat for daily wear to minimize flaking
- Use mineral oil for most effective removal
- Consider using it as a topcoat over a non-waterproof mascara for easier removal while maintaining waterproof benefits
The Verdict
MAC’s Waterproof Mascara delivers impressively on its core waterproof promise but falls short in consistency and longevity. Its performance can be characterized as a tale of two mascaras: excellent initially, but rapidly declining in quality after opening.
For those who have struggled to find a truly waterproof mascara that doesn’t smudge or run, this product may be worth the investment despite its flaws. The peace of mind that comes with knowing your mascara won’t betray you during emotional moments, sweaty situations, or water activities carries significant value for many users.
However, the rapid deterioration in formula consistency and the prevalence of flaking issues make it difficult to recommend unconditionally, especially at its premium price point. Those seeking an everyday mascara with consistent performance throughout the life of the product may find better value elsewhere.
Final Rating: 3.5/5 Stars
Pros:
- Genuinely waterproof in most conditions
- Excellent lengthening capabilities
- No smudging or raccoon eyes
- Precision application with the rounded brush tip
- Stays on all day without touch-ups
Cons:
- Formula thickens and clumps quickly after opening
- Flaking issues reported by many users
- Difficult removal process
- Short effective lifespan in the tube
- Some quality control issues with packaging
Purchasing Considerations
If you decide to try MAC’s Waterproof Mascara, consider the following:
- Purchase from retailers with generous return policies given the reported quality control issues
- Be prepared to invest in a good oil-based makeup remover
- Set realistic expectations about the product’s lifespan after opening
- Consider whether the truly waterproof performance justifies the premium price and potential downsides
For many, this mascara represents a specialized tool in their beauty arsenal rather than an everyday staple—perfect for specific occasions when waterproof performance is non-negotiable, but perhaps not ideal for daily use.
Whether MAC’s Waterproof Mascara deserves a place in your makeup collection ultimately depends on your specific needs, priorities, and budget. Its performance polarizes users, creating both devoted fans and disappointed detractors. What remains clear is that when it comes to staying power through water, sweat, and tears, few mascaras can match its performance—if you can overlook its other shortcomings.
Buy on Amazon: Here