Hey beauty lovers! Today I’m excited to dive deep into one of my favorite makeup must-haves – the Mac Pro Palette Eye Shadow x 15 Insert. As a long-time Mac fan and eyeshadow aficionado, I’ve had a chance to really put this palette through its paces. I’ve analyzed a bunch of customer reviews to get a well-rounded take on what makes this product so great (and maybe a couple areas it could improve). So grab your brushes and let’s get into it!
Pros
- Convenient, customizable palette system
- Ability to curate your perfect shade collection
- Saves space compared to individual shadow pots
- High quality, long-wearing, blendable shadows
- Durable, easy to clean palette
- Travel-friendly
- Affordable compared to buying shades individually
Cons
- Some difficulty depotting shadows from individual pots
- Have to purchase shades separately from empty palette
- Minor issues with shadows staying in place for some
One thing that immediately stands out is how much people love the refillable palette concept. As Tay gushes in her review, “I love that MAC offers refill eyeshadows and custom palette inserts. It allows you to make your own eyeshadow palette full of all your favorite eyeshadows.” This customization factor is huge – instead of being stuck with pre-made color stories that inevitably include shades you’ll never use, you can carefully curate your dream palette with only your most-loved and most-used colors.
Plus, as many point out, consolidating your single shadows into palettes is a major space-saver. Lee shares, “I feel silly that I had not been using a Pro Palette and Insert sooner. I had lots of little pots of Mac shadow but could not see everything easily and it took up so much space. This is so much better!” I can totally relate – those single pots are cute but they take up way too much precious vanity real estate.
The quality and performance of the eyeshadows themselves also get top marks from reviewers. Words like “blendable”, “highly pigmented”, “long-wearing”, and even “waterproof” crop up frequently in the review snippets, reinforcing Mac’s well-earned reputation for top-notch formulas. As HK raves, this palette delivers “Bold Color, Crease Resistant, Highly Pigmented, Long-wearing, Moisturizing, Natural Looking, Waterproof” shades. Sounds like everything you could want in an eyeshadow!
Convenience is another big selling point many touch on. Being able to choose your own shades and have them all in one sleek palette makes this a go-to for everyday use and travel. Greeneyes proclaims the Pro Palette “absolutely the best at keeping your favourite shadows in one complete case” and loves that they’re “just the handiest, perfect things for every day use and travel.” Having all your best colors organized and easily accessible in one place is a huge timesaver, especially when you’re rushing to get ready in the morning.
The sturdiness and design of the palette itself is another highlight. Several users describe it as “durable” and praise how easy it is to clean. Palette_creativity_savvvy applauds, “They are durable, easy to clean and assemble and worth it for the price.” Investing in a good quality palette that will hold up to daily use and travel is so important for us busy beauty lovers on the go.
Speaking of price, while Mac is a prestige brand, many feel the Pro Palette inserts offer great value, especially if you take advantage of the Back-to-Mac recycling program. By purchasing refill pans and the empty palette separately, you can save compared to buying potted shadows. AZMAKEUPBIN breaks it down, explaining, “These high shadow palette inserts…are very affordable, they come in many variations of sizes, and I love that you can rearrange your shades depending on certain looks you’re trying to create!” It’s awesome to have a luxury-level product that delivers on quality while still being budget-friendly.
Now, no product is perfect, and there were a few minor critiques mixed in with all the rave reviews. Some, like Mac, found depotting shadows from their individual pots to be a bit finicky: “It was harder than I thought to get the other pans out of their individual cases but worth it so I could keep my favorites together.” Others wish the empty palette was included when purchasing the eyeshadow refills, like Karine who notes, “It’s unfortunate you have to pay when you buy it with colors.”
A few people seem to have had some issues with the eyeshadows staying firmly in place in the palette, although this doesn’t appear to be a widespread problem. As Coco shares, “I bought this insert because I have way too many eyeshadows. It does the trick for what I need. My eyeshadows stay in place. So I’m not sure what the others are talking about.” Still, it’s something to be aware of. Making sure the shadows are fully clicked into place and being gentle when traveling with the palette can help prevent any disasters.
At the end of the day though, the vast majority of users are thrilled with their Pro Palettes and would heartily recommend them to fellow makeup lovers. The ability to create a fully personalized eyeshadow wardrobe, the exceptional quality and performance of the shades, and the attractive price point make this a real standout.
If I had to summarize the key benefits that crop up over and over in these reviews, it would be:
- Customization – being able to create your own perfect palette
- Convenience – having all your go-to shades organized in one place
- Quality – Mac’s always-impressive color payoff, blendability, and wear time
- Sturdiness – a durable palette that stands up to regular use
- Value – a prestige product at an affordable price, especially with the refill system
All in all, I really can’t argue with Greeneyes’ final take: “Oh, do I LOVE these 15 and 9 compartment cases! They are absolutely the best at keeping your favourite shadows in one complete case…These cases are just the handiest, perfect things for every day use and travel. Nothing compares.”
After really digging into these reviews and reflecting on my own experience with the product, I’m more convinced than ever that the Mac Pro Palette is an absolute essential for any serious eyeshadow enthusiast. Having the freedom to create your ultimate color collection, the incredible formula and lasting power of Mac’s shadows, and the sleek, portable packaging all combine to make this a true makeup MVP.
Yes, depotting your shadows and needing to purchase the insert separately can be a tiny bit annoying. But the process is really quite simple once you get the hang of it. And frankly, the ability to curate your own ideal palette and streamline your stash is well worth the minimal effort and expense in my book. I’d rather have a single, perfectly customized palette I can use every day than a dozen pre-made ones gathering dust!
For me, this is the palette I reach for again and again, whether I’m doing a quick wash of color for the office or a bolder look for evening. The shades always perform beautifully, and having them all in one well-organized case makes getting ready a breeze. I also love being able to swap in new shades as my collection grows and my preferences change. The Pro Palette evolves right along with my makeup needs and moods!
If you couldn’t tell, I give this product an enthusiastic two thumbs up. Whether you’re a Mac devotee or new to the brand, a budding eyeshadow collector or a seasoned pro, I highly recommend giving the Pro Palette a try. Choose your favorite 9 or 15 shades from Mac’s vast array of stellar hues, pop them into your palette, and enjoy the satisfaction of having your dream color wardrobe at your fingertips. Just be warned – once you experience the joy of a perfectly personalized palette, you may never go back to premade again!
So what do you think? Have you tried the Mac Pro Palette system? If so, what has your experience been like? If not, are you tempted to give it a whirl after hearing from so many happy customers? Do you prefer palettes you can customize or do you like the convenience and curation of pre-filled ones? Let me know in the comments below!
I hope this deep dive was helpful and maybe even a little enabling (sorry not sorry)! Wishing you all the best on your quest for the perfect eyeshadow palette. Until next time, stay beautiful!
Buy on Amazon: Here
