The vast majority of reviewers had very positive things to say about the MAC Prep + Prime Highlighter. Common words used to describe it were: blendable, natural-looking, brightening, and moisturizing. Many raved that it was their holy grail under eye product. The average rating across all the reviews was 4.5 out of 5 stars, indicating strong customer satisfaction overall.
There were a few low ratings, but they seemed to be the exception rather than the norm. The most common complaints were around specific shades being discontinued, the applicator not dispensing product well, and a few instances of it creasing or not providing enough coverage for very dark under eye circles.
Key Benefits Mentioned
Reviewers highlighted a number of major pros and benefits of this product:
- Brightening: One of the most frequently praised aspects was how well this highlighter pen brightens the under eye area. Numerous reviewers said it made them look more awake and radiant.
- Blendable: Another top mention was how easy this is to blend out. Customers appreciated that it melts into the skin for a seamless finish.
- Natural-Looking: While this provides good brightening, many reviewers emphasized that the effect is natural, not obvious or glittery. It seems to give a lit-from-within type glow.
- Long-Wearing: Quite a few reviewers said this lasts well on them throughout the day without fading. Some mentioned it working well even on long work days or in hot weather.
- Crease-Resistant: Another common benefit was that this doesn’t settle into fine lines or creases under the eyes. Many highlighted this as a major plus compared to other concealers.
- Moisturizing: Those with dry under eyes appreciated that this has a hydrating, creamy texture. It doesn’t appear to cling to or emphasize dry patches.
- Multi-Purpose: Customers found this worked well in a variety of ways – as an under eye brightener, all-over highlighter, eyeshadow base, spot concealer, foundation mixer, etc. The versatility was a selling point.
Shades
The main shades mentioned were Radiant Rose, Peach Lustre and Bright Forecast. Radiant Rose seemed to be the most popular and a cult favorite for all skin tones. Several reviewers were very upset that it was discontinued.
Peach Lustre worked well for color correcting on tan to deep skin tones. Bright Forecast was better for fair to light skin as a brightening shade. A few thought Peach Lustre was too orange and Bright Forecast was too pink, wishing there was a more neutral undertone option.
Application Tips
Reviewers shared some helpful tips for getting the most out of this product:
- Color Correcting: Many recommended using this as a color corrector under concealer/foundation. Dabbing it on before other coverage products seemed to give the best results.
- Priming the Pen: The click-style pen can take some getting used to. You may need to twist it quite a few times when it’s brand new to get the product flowing.
- Letting it Set: Some found that dabbing this on, letting it dry down for a minute, then blending gave better coverage vs. immediately rubbing it in.
- Brightening: In addition to using under the eyes, reviewers also liked putting this in other spots for brightness – down the nose, on the brow bone, cupid’s bow, etc.
Who It’s Best For
Based on the customer feedback, this highlighter pen seems to work especially well for:
- Those with mild under eye darkness or dullness
- Mature skin that wants a hydrating, crease-resistant formula
- Anyone who prefers a natural makeup look
- Those who like a subtly radiant, but not sparkly, highlight
- People who want a multi-tasking product for brightening, color correcting and highlighting
It may be less ideal for:
- Very deep or severe under eye circles that need heavy duty coverage
- Those with extremely oily under eyes (may break down faster)
- People who prefer a very matte, non-reflective finish
Final Thoughts
Overall, the MAC Prep + Prime Highlighter seems to be a stellar product based on the extensive positive customer reviews. If you’re looking for an easy way to brighten, color correct and highlight in one step, this is definitely worth checking out. The lightweight, blendable texture and natural radiant finish make it suitable for a wide variety of ages and skin types.
While there are a few caveats like the pen applicator taking some getting used to, the discontinuation of certain shades, and it not being full coverage enough for some, the vast majority of users had glowing praise for this holy grail product. I personally can’t wait to try it myself after reading all the rave reviews! Let me know in the comments if you’ve ever used this and what your experience was.
Buy on Amazon: Here
