Hey beauty lovers! Today we’re diving deep into MAC Cosmetics’ Fix+ Stay Over Alcohol-Free 24HR Setting Spray. As a long-time fan of MAC’s original Fix+, I was thrilled to get my hands on this new alcohol-free, long-wearing formula promising up to 24 hours of makeup lock-down. I’ve pored over 100 customer reviews and put this setting spray through its paces to bring you the full scoop. Let’s get into it!
First Impressions
Right off the bat, the pretty pink packaging caught my eye. It’s cute and eye-catching while still feeling distinctly MAC. Several reviewers commented on the pleasant, light scent—nothing too overpowering or chemical. Personally, I barely noticed a fragrance which is a plus in my book.
The spray nozzle seems to be a point of contention. Many praised the fine, even mist it delivers, a step up from the original Fix+. “The spray is pretty good and doesn’t spray all wild or uneven which is really nice,” noted one reviewer.
However, others experienced major issues with clogging, jamming, and leaking, sometimes rendering the product unusable with plenty left in the bottle. Consistency seems to be lacking here, and for a premium product, that’s disappointing. MAC, if you’re reading, the people have spoken—work on that nozzle!
The Wear Test
Alright, let’s get to the good stuff—how does this setting spray actually perform? I tested it over a full face of makeup through long workdays, nights out, and even a sweaty gym session.
The results? Pretty darn impressive. My makeup looked freshly applied after 12+ hour days, with minimal fading or creasing. I was especially struck by how well my blush and highlighter held up—usually the first to disappear on me. Even after a workout, my base wasn’t melting off my face. That’s a win in my book.
Many reviewers shared similar experiences, raving about how their makeup lasted from morning application to evening removal, through heat, humidity, and oily skin. “Keeps everything looking fresh from the start of my day at 6am until I wrap up my night,” one reviewer enthused.
That said, a few people with very oily skin found it didn’t fully control shine throughout the day. As with any product, individual results may vary. But overall, Fix+ Stay Over looks like a solid bet for seriously extending makeup wear.
The Finish
One thing I love about the original Fix+ is how it melds makeup into skin for a natural, seamless finish. I’m happy to report Stay Over delivers on that front too. It takes down any powderiness or cakiness, creating a skin-like effect that still leans matte—great if you’re oily like me.
Reviewers across skin types appreciated this natural, perfected look. “Makes your makeup look flawless at the end,” “Gives you a dewy look,” and “Makes my makeup pop” are just a few of the enthused comments. Some found it a bit tacky until fully dried down, but smooth sailing after that.
A handful of people did experience the spray disrupting their makeup, particularly around the under-eye, so exercise some caution there. But by and large, Fix+ Stay Over seems to play beautifully with a variety of foundation formulas to create a your-skin-but-better finish that stays put.
The Skincare Benefits
Here’s where Fix+ Stay Over really distinguishes itself. The alcohol-free formula is packed with skincare goodies like hyaluronic acid, niacinamide, and vitamin C for hydration, barrier support, and antioxidant benefits.
I’m always wary of setting sprays drying out or irritating my reactive skin, but this one felt great. Reviewers with sensitive skin echoed that sentiment, with one noting “It didn’t irritate my skin and it locked my makeup into place.”
Those with dry skin especially appreciated the spray’s moisturizing properties. Not once or twice but every time I wear it has this MAC Cosmetics Fix+ Stay Over Setting Spray saved my make up,” one review glowed. “I can truly say it’s very worth it!”
As a skincare junkie, I love a product that delivers both instant and long-term benefits, and Fix+ Stay Over does just that. The fact that it helps defend against environmental stressors like pollution and blue light is a cherry on top. More of this in the beauty space, please!
Comparing to Other Setting Sprays
Of course, Fix+ Stay Over isn’t the only gig in town. Many reviewers stacked it up against other popular setting sprays on the market.
Urban Decay’s All Nighter was a frequent point of comparison, with some preferring one or the other. One reviewer found Fix+ Stay Over far superior at oil control and extending the wear of liner, while another thought All Nighter had the edge. Ultimately, it likely comes down to individual skin chemistry and preferences.
Other favorites like Morphe’s Continuous Setting Mist and Dermablend Lock and Last were also mentioned. A few reviewers found Fix+ Stay Over came out on top, with one former Morphe fan saying “it sets and dries super quick in a matte finish. No ‘oil’ looking film layer. I completely fell in love!”
At $36 for 3.4 oz, Fix+ Stay Over is definitely a luxury buy. Some found the price tag hard to justify, especially given the risk of a faulty nozzle, while others thought the high-end experience was worth the cost. “I will for sure purchase the large size once I finish this one,” one reviewer declared.
The Bottom Line
So, is Fix+ Stay Over worth the hype? Based on my experience and the bulk of these reviews, I’m going to say yes, with a few caveats.
If you’re looking for a setting spray that will truly go the distance keeping your makeup looking fresh and flawless, this is a fantastic option. The lightweight formula locks everything in place without feeling heavy or sticky, and the skincare benefits are a big bonus. It’s a great choice for dry, sensitive, or mature skin in particular.
However, the issues with the spray nozzle are concerning. Paying luxury prices for a product that might break after a few uses is frustrating to say the least. This seems to be a quality control problem MAC needs to correct. Their customer service is generally great, but who wants to keep exchanging faulty bottles?
Additionally, if you’re extremely oily and need an ultra-matte, oil-controlling finish, Fix+ Stay Over may not be your holy grail. It definitely helped my oily T-zone, but I still got a bit shiny by end of day. If that’s a dealbreaker, you might prefer something like Urban Decay De-Slick.
Overall though, I’ve thoroughly enjoyed using Fix+ Stay Over and will continue to reach for it, especially on long days. If MAC can improve the packaging consistency, I think they’ll have a real winner on their hands. It combines the best qualities of the original Fix+ (that seamless finish and refreshing feel) with impressive staying power and the skincare benefits dry, reactive skin like mine craves.
So, is Fix+ Stay Over Alcohol-Free 24HR Setting Spray going to be your makeup bag’s new MVP? The only way to know is to try it for yourself and see how it meshes with your unique skin. But if you’re looking for a clean, luxurious setting spray that keeps your beat locked in for the long haul, I definitely recommend giving it a shot.
Have you tried MAC Fix+ Stay Over? I’d love to hear about your experience and how it stacks up against your tried-and-true setting sprays. Leave me a comment and let’s chat all things makeup longevity!
Until next time, beauty lovers, may your makeup stay flawless no matter where the day takes you. XOXO
Buy on Amazon: Here
